My Thoughts on the New Star Wars Movies

I saw the latest Star Wars movie, Solo, with some friends a couple of weeks ago. I found it very surprising that the movie is struggling so much at the box office. Solo was the safest of all Star Wars films and actually worked really well for what it was trying to achieve. I don’t completely agree with the casting choice for Han Solo, but the film definitely worked and was fun to watch. Why is Solo struggling so much?

han-solo-movie-poster-star-wars-characters-revealed

Of course, there are many theories as to why Solo is having box office woes. The more popular theories are that a crowded market along with releasing another Star Wars film right after the Last Jedi led to poor numbers. Some state that no one really wanted a Solo movie anyways while there are others who think that this is a result of the Last Jedi being a poor movie.

That got me thinking about the overall direction of the Star Wars franchise under Disney. The debate in the fan community hit a fever pitch with the Last Jedi, when a strong backlash from fans attacked the movie as the worst Star Wars movie of all time. Now I myself enjoyed the Last Jedi. And in general, I’ve enjoyed the new movies. But the direction they’ve taken is an interesting one.

star-wars-episode-7-i32195

I’m going to start with the current trilogy. The set up is very similar to that of the original trilogy. We have the remnants of the Empire and the Resistance, a group of ragtag fighters opposed to the remnants of the Empire (the First Order). Of course, this does seem ‘almost’ like the Original Trilogy, and to many it seems too similar. I would point out that the Empire was not ‘destroyed’ at the Battle of Endor. The Emperor had died and the second Death Star destroyed. Much of the Imperial capability was probably still in place.

first-order-troops-and-money

For a moment, let’s leave the actual canonical timeline aside, since, let’s be fair, many would not be familiar with it (though I did look it up, and if you are interested in seeing the timeline of events after the Battle of Endor, you can find it here). So commenting on just what we are seeing in Episode 7: it’s interesting that the movie went with a familiar setup as that of Episode 4 and the Original Trilogy. But this isn’t the most unrealistic set-up for a post Battle of Endor world. The Empire was the dominant political force in the galaxy, and many would fight tooth and nail to maintain the order if solely because of how it benefitted their position. Moreover, defeating that force would take time. The Empire is still a very well equipped fighting force. The Rebel Alliance was, by the nature of being a rebellion, probably not the best fighting force/political force. There would be quite a bit of conflict before the Empire is either defeated or forced to surrender. And there would still be many of the former political structure who would probably remain very loyal to that structure simply because of how much they lost upon collapse and/or had during the reign of the Empire. So it is entirely conceivable that the Empire would devolve into something very similar to the Empire and attempt to rebuild.

The New Republic would probably not be a strong state either. The Empire ruled for about 25 or so years, according to the timeline, and even by only what we see in the movies, the Empire was implied to be ruling for quite some time by the time of the first film. The New Republic would only just have reorganized into a new state and had about 20 or so years, given the ages of the protagonists involved. Probably not enough time for a new government to really consolidate into something more powerful.

The point? It’s not entirely unconceivable that the Empire would collapse and reform into something like the First Order. It’s also not at all inconceivable that the New Republic would have a difficult time realizing that a new threat has risen. There is some very strong historical precedence for this: World War 1. After Germany was defeated, about 20 years went by. In that time, the German Empire became the Weimar Republic, which then became Nazi Germany. Nazi Germany was ignored for quite some time by the other nations of Europe until fairly late in the series of events that occurred.

rey-main_73d146de

This isn’t to say that Episode 7’s similarities are entirely justified, but that the setup of the new movies makes a fair amount of sense. There are things I didn’t like with Episode 7. I didn’t like the use of a Death Star-esque super weapon at the end of the film. This is my single largest criticism of the movie in that there could’ve been any number of better ways to go about this that are more inventive, more novel, and cooler, but instead the filmmakers played it safe with a very familiar type of super-weapon. The ending of the movie could have been fantastic. Instead we had to settle with a ‘good’ ending. Rey has beginnings that are extremely similar to Luke Skywalker, which while isn’t terrible in itself, given how her character progresses, it’s not the best either. I can see though why they did this: they wanted to make a familiar setting. It’s sort of nitpicking on my part, but it was one of the things I didn’t like.

starwarsmilitary-final

I did also examine the movies aesthetically. Aesthetically, the vehicles and various ships of the new movies look very similar to the original trilogy as well. One of the more interesting things about the prequel trilogy is how different the Old Republic ships and military looked from the Empire. A lot seems to have changed in what is a relatively short timespan. By contrast, little seems to have changed between the time of the Battle of Endor and the New Republic. Some see this as a weak point of the new movies and lack of imagination. Certainly that ‘could’ be a reason. There does also seem to be the desire to keep a similar aesthetic. But let’s examine the US military in the last 20 years (from 1998 to 2018): the US Air Force still makes use of aircraft from the ’60s (such as the B-52) and other aircraft such as F-16s, F/A-18s, and other aircraft. The US Navy has seen less changes, whereas the US Army has seen some changes. In that sense, it makes a lot of sense that there would be little change in the military systems used by the New Republic.

Episode 7’s characters were compelling. Rey was mysterious, more so than Luke Skywalker was in Episode 4. Finn had an interesting background of being a defector Stormtrooper. It was even more interesting to see where the characters from the Original Trilogy ended up. This is, in my opinion, a central contention point about the new movies. The Expanded Universe tended to depict these characters as being successful and central to everything that ever occurred afterwards along with their family lines. The new trilogy, by contrast, depicts a much bleaker picture. Certainly we have Kylo Ren, who is indeed from the Solo/Skywalker family line, but Han Solo is a washed up smuggler once more, and Luke himself a broken man, as we see later on in Episode 8. Only Leia seems to be somewhat more successful in the sense that she is leading the Resistance against the First Order. It’s an interesting way to start off the new trilogy where our triumphant heroes from the Original Trilogy are heavily affected by their perceived failures. It also opens up the door to a new generation of heroes for a new time. I understand why Disney went this route as opposed to giving a larger and bigger role to the original heroes. Disney did want to tell a new story of new people rather than a story of the same old characters. It’s also why we see the old characters being ‘killed off’ to an extent. But it does lead to some very interesting moments as well. The scene where Kylo Ren kills Han Solo is a very intense and moving scene, probably the high point of Episode 7. It really builds the villain character in a way that the original trilogy did not. We see this continue in Episode 8 that way.

finn-main_952e10d2

This starts to get us a bit into Episode 8. Episode 7 may have been very similar to the original trilogy movies, but it was still very recognizably a Star Wars movie because of that. Episode 8, on the other hand, completely turned the recognizable Star Wars tropes on their head. As far as I can tell, this was Rian Johnson’s goal. This movie was the single most polarizing Star Wars film in recent memory. Episode 8 shows a lot of failure on the part of our new heroes. In fact, that was the most common theme in the movie. Episode 8 took a lot of risks in that sense: it was not very familiar to other Star Wars movies. It had some nods to Episode V of course, but only minimally. The only real similarity is that the good guys are running away from the bad guys and attempting to regroup (and of course there was a scene where the First Order sends in AT-AT walkers, but it bares little resemblance beyond the aesthetic to the Battle of Hoth). Episode 8 did not go the way anyone expected, and that in itself is polarizing (such as Rey being essentially a nobody, which is pretty cool I think). I thought Episode 8 was better than 7 in that sense alone: it took risks and most of those risks paid off. Episode 7 was far too safe by comparison, but still a solid movie. Episode 8 firmly established that the next movie will take the franchise in a very different direction than the original trilogy.

There were a lot of risks taken in this movie. For one, all of the heroes fail initially. This can seem a bit that the movie is entirely pointless, but the idea is that failure, and major failure, is a part of the struggles of any character. Overcoming those failures is what makes them heroic, which they do so at the end. Another risk taken was Kylo Ren and him killing Snoke. There was quite a bit of debate around this point. It does establish that Kylo Ren may indeed be a very irredeemable villain, unlike Anakin Skywalker. It’s also a great way to build his character as a villain: we see a ruthless side of Ren and his rise to a new status as leader of the First Order. Of course, many were quick to point out that Snoke is killed off without us ever learning who he is and what his motivations are. This is an interesting point. We don’t know much about Snoke, other than vague details on his central role building the Empire and vague details on him corrupting Ben Solo. Snoke’s importance is up for debate, given that we don’t have the last movie yet. About all that’s known is that the First Order wants to reestablish a Galactic Empire again, similar to the first one. And perhaps that’s all we need to know about Snoke. Maybe it’s all that matters. Again, this was a risky approach, and one that pays off in my opinion since it gives Kylo’s character that much more weight.

star-wars-luke-skywalker-deluxe-sixth-scale-hot-toys-feature-903204

Of course, we can’t talk about Episode 8 without talking about Luke Skywalker. Luke, as mentioned earlier, is a broken man. His failure with Kylo Ren, the moment of weakness that nearly lead to him killing Kylo Ren, breaks him. Kylo Ren’s background gets more weight once more as a result. The original trilogy never dives much into the details of why Anakin Skywalker becomes Darth Vader (that task is left to the prequel trilogy, unfortunately). And of course, it doesn’t mythify the old heroes: they aren’t larger than life legends. They can fail, which is a large theme of this movie, much as Yoda does state to Luke in the movie itself. This is a major break from what Luke Skywalker was in the old movies and what he became in the Expanded Universe. It is a major break from the old trilogy itself. Again, it’s a risk, and it does create a great dynamic for all the characters, and provides some great background and character building for the events in the movie.

canto-bight_6782d4fa

There are some aspects of the movie that are perhaps not quite as well done. There’s the much criticized sequence on Canto Blight: it doesn’t seem to add any value to the overall film and slows down pacing. There is some truth to this criticism. The issue isn’t necessarily that the subplot exists at all but rather what it tries to accomplish. In the end we see that the characters fail, which is fine: it keeps with the theme of the movie. But the payoff isn’t quite there with this subplot. With Rey’s subplot, we learn more about Luke and about Kylo Ren. There’s the whole aspect of Rey and Ren communicating with one another. There’s the interesting scene with Rey asking about her parents. With Canto Blight, we have none of that. It falls flat compared to other aspects of the movie. It can be shortened or should have some more compelling content. A lot could’ve been learned about the First Order, and its supporters, or its origins, as examples. Finn is left fairly underdeveloped as a result of this sequence as well, since it does not add anything to his character.

For some, the humor didn’t work either. I liked the humor, but it’s easy for me to see why many would not like it. The humor is very jarring, and for those who simply don’t like it, it can detract from the movie somewhat.

Episode 8 also shifts from a triumphant Resistance to a Resistance on the run, which for many did not make much sense. Had the Resistance not just won a major victory by destroying Starkiller Base? How is the First Order winning suddenly? It is worth noting that the new Death Star variant was destroyed after destroying an entire major system of the New Republic (the capital, as we later fight out). It’s not much of a stretch to imagine that the New Republic would be in chaos after a surprise attack of that magnitude. The First Order must clearly have had plenty of assets available to build a weapon like Starkiller Base, so for them to go on the offensive would not be difficult in a moment like this.

ep8-ff-006360_c95dace6

It’s also fairly important to note that many fan questions centered around unexplained background or points. Who was Snoke? What is the First Order? Why is their a First Order? What happened to the New Republic? Why isn’t there more armed resistance? Why is Rey so powerful with the Force? There are far too many questions for a single (or even two) movie of about 2 hours length to answer, and this movie was two and a half hours long. The issue here is that Disney is attempting to make sequels to the original trilogy. With that, naturally, comes a lot of questions, especially given how long people’s imaginations have worked at creating more of the universe of Star Wars since then. The original trilogy itself had very little background for many of the things that the new Star Wars movies had been questioned on, but it worked then since those were the first movies of its kind and made in a very different era. Now expectations are different, since we’ve gotten not only the Expanded Universe but also entire prequel movies. If the new movies tried to examine every nuance of the universe after Return of the Jedi, we’d probably end up with a 5 hour documentary instead of watchable movies. It’s a very difficult task to accomplish, one that cannot be done without leaving some things unexplained. It’s also worth pointing out that many of these questions on ‘plot holes’ or unexplained aspects of the movie were very much present in the original trilogy as well. That and to those of us who liked Episode 8, it seemed a bit like nitpicking. There is definitely a point beyond which I cannot quite say why some of these questions and criticisms matter so much.

Episode 8 does set up Episode 9 for some very interesting potential directions. Kylo Ren may very well be irredeemable. There are plenty of possibilities with Rey, and with the rest of the New Republic and other systems that were simply watching and waiting. There’s a lot that can be explored.

rogue-one-character-line-up

This post has been quite long, but I can’t finish talking about the new franchise without talking about the spin off movies. Rogue One was arguably the best movie of the new films and perhaps of all Star Wars in my opinion. Rogue One did something that Star Wars has not done before in film: it examined the darker aspects of the universe. The Rebel Alliance and the Empire are not as black and white in this movie as they are in other Star Wars films. Jyn Erso is far from the heroic characters of the original movies. Cassian is more than willing to assassinate anyone who gets in the way of his mission, and also to carry out questionable missions in the name of the Rebellion. The tone is not one of adventure but one of desperation in the face of an oppressive and brutal force. The Empire is depicted as a brutal dictatorship but not everyone in the Empire is an evil person. Galin Erso is a scientist forced into his role. The acts of resistance are often unnoticed but consequential. There isn’t a happy ending in this movie: every major character dies to achieve the goal. There’s a lot of deaths and warfare in general. It ends on a hopeful note since the mission is successful but the costs are quite high. This movie, above all others, showcases the potential that the new Star Wars films have.

And finally, onto the Solo movie. The Solo movie continues the trend of looking at the harsher side of the Empire in more ways but is more lighthearted than Rogue One was. I think the major shortcoming of this movie perhaps was that Han Solo was not a character that many of us really cared to know more about. The movie itself was more on the safer side, not necessarily bad, but a bit less risk taking than previous films have been. It isn’t as much a misstep of a movie itself so much as the decision to make a movie on Han Solo made less sense than, say, making a movie on Boba Fett, or on Obi Wan.

screen-shot-2016-12-24-at-1-43-47-pm

This leads me into the future of the franchise. We know there’s of course, Episode 9 around the corner, but there will also be two new trilogies, a TV show, and continued spin off movies. One of the things we have not yet seen explored at all is the Clone Wars. We don’t like talking much about the prequel movies, considering how terrible the first two were at least, but the Clone Wars is a period that’s barely explored in the films. It would be interesting to see some adventures there. There is, also, an entire Old Republic era to explore. And, there’s also the intervening time period between the fall of the Empire and the rise of the First Order to look into. There’s a lot that the movies can explore and I’m all for more films actually. Episode 9 itself looks like it’ll have quite an interesting set up to go forward from.

I’m fairly excited to see what the next Star Wars movies have in store for us.

Advertisements

Random Art Pieces: The Entombed Courtyard

Hey all,

So as I said in my other post on the Garud Mk. 1, I needed a break, so I decided to make this piece.

The first attempt:

feb12render1

The second attempt with errors:

feb13render

The corrected second attempt:

feb13render2

The third version (one of the finals) with increased lighting:

feb13render3

Lowered lighting of the third:

feb13render4

This final version: uses lighting in between the preceding two

feb13render5

As always, like, subscribe, and share!

I’d love to hear feedback as well!

Random Art Pieces: The Hallway

My posting frequency has decreased quite a bit, I realize. There’s been a ton going on, and now I’m actually technically on vacation. I’ve gotten more time now, so I’m hoping to post a bit more. Anyhow, this is a piece I worked on for a couple of days as part of the quick pieces that I try to do. It’s nowhere near perfect, obviously, but it’s always fun to take a short break and throw together these pieces. Here’s the piece:

theHallwayDec25

I’m still working primarily on the Garud Mk. 1 model, which is progressing quite nicely. I hope to design some other things as well actually. Happy Holidays everyone!

Random Art Pieces

Hey all,

So I have to admit, at times I find it tough to focus on larger pieces. So what I’m doing now is hoping to take short breaks and create roughly weekly pieces of art as a means of trying out new things and just doing simple stuff for fun that is relatively quick to do. I like to call these pieces ‘sketches’. Last week was the building/skyscraper piece. This week is also sort of architectural related and a bit on the darker side. It’s an interior, and meant to be something like a cell/dungeon. Here are some pics!

cellRender1cellRender2cellRender3

It’s not perfect. It could use more work. Really, I spent something like 4 hours or so on this scene. I had a vision in my head and figured that I could probably make this and I aimed for maximum photorealism here. It’s not quite there honestly. I figured I’d share it anyways.

Check back later for more random stuff I throw together!

As always, like, subscribe, and share!

Thanksgiving Update!

Hey all,

First and foremost, to my US based readers, happy Thanksgiving! It’s finally getting into the holiday season! I’m pretty pumped and looking forward to some off time!

I realize that I haven’t written at all recently, and honestly, there haven’t been too many updates to give. I’m still modeling the Garud Mk. 1 fighter, and I will post some screenshots soon, but progress has been relatively slow on this project. I’m also writing a ton these days, and I’m actually thinking of maybe sending my manuscript for publishing. I’m also considering making a small game, using the Unity engine. In short, there’s a ton going on, a lot of it has to do with what I want to focus on, and as a result, my blogging has lagged a bit.

But today is Thanksgiving, and I had some off time, unfortunately not near my main computer, but I messed around a bit with some textures to make some basic stuff! Check it out!

skyscraper1

skyscraper2skyscraper5skyscraper6skyscraperClampedskyscraperRusted

skyscraper7

skyscraperHD.jpg

I’m pretty proud of the last one actually. This was mainly a test/exercise for texturing and modeling and just playing around in general. I’ll post some updates on the fighter project soon!

As always, like, subscribe, and share!

My ZBrush Owl 3D Print Arrived!

So after finishing up my ZBrush sculpt of the owl, it took some time to get it printed. I initially tried to get it printed in porcelain, but unfortunately, my sculpt had some structural flaws, so I had to use a different material. I then opted to use plastic, and the results are pretty good. Here’s some pictures:

IMG_1665IMG_1666IMG_1667IMG_1668IMG_1669Shapeways did a great job with it. I love how even my tiniest details got through into the 3d print! It’s not very large, unfortunately, but any larger would’ve been a bit too much for my first 3d print. I’m very happy with how the model came out. Here’s the ZBrush pics for comparison:
Screen Shot 2017-06-12 at 8.37.50 AMScreen Shot 2017-06-12 at 8.37.35 AM

Most of the detail came through, and the model, much to my surprise, is capable of standing on its own! I hadn’t expected that too work out!

 

Update: What Am I Doing and My Plans

So it’s been some time since I last posted, mainly because I’ve been abroad. As I mentioned earlier, this is the reason that I haven’t been working on models for the Mahayudh Chronicles. The major reason is that I wanted to incorporate some of what I’d see here into my work. So therefore, expect things like this to become part of my modeling:


What you’re looking at is pictures of the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba, la catedral de Barcelona, and la catedral de Granada (in no particular order). As you know, I’ve modeled one cathedral before (la catedral de Segovia), but in this case, I will be incorporating many of the architectural styles seen here into my own models, so they’ll be different, but with a  distinct inspiration.

Now this doesn’t mean that I will be abandoning the Emperor Class project. I will continue to work on it. The Emperor Class style warship has some more details left to model in. The top of the bridge, the central command window, and some more top side cannons still need to be modeled. There’s also details underneath the broadside cannons that need to be added, along with another layer in general of different pieces here and there to add in. It’s not a ton of geometry left. Thing is that I am fast approaching the limits of what geometry can add to this model. Ultimately I have to move on to texturing, so the next part will be UV unwrapping (sigh) and texturing, probably using Substance Painter and Substance Designer.

Finally, I will also begin a new ZBrush sculpt of an owl. This project is ultimately something that I will 3d print as a gift for someone. Nonetheless, it will also be a part of my CG work coming up.

As for what to expect here on The Explorator, there’s going to be progress updates for everything I’ve just posted, along with a new serialized fiction story coming soon as well. This new story will not make use of any visuals in its initial run. Perhaps after it’s finished, I may make some CGI for it in terms of single images just for fun.

There’s loads to expect and a ton to keep me busy, so stay tuned!

As always, like, subscribe, and share!

Progress Update: Lambertian Render Tests and More Geometry Detail

I’ve had some time to sit down and model out the battleship project. I also decided to throw in a dome light and do some renders without any textures. Here’s some results:

lambert1lambert2lambert3lambert4lambert5lambert6

I really love the lambert render, since it makes everything look so much better, even though it’s nowhere near finished. I have added tons of details to the ship but am still nowhere near finished. I’ve added side facing large cannons for taking down capital ships, energy coils on the stern, more gothic windows, and what will eventually become a hangar on the underside of the ship. I’ve also started to model in the domes on the bridge and added details to the bridge as well. There are a lot of things I’ve added, but there’s still more to go. There are parts of the ship that I feel are still too plain, where I might add some detail. Mainly, the bridge pieces will have much more modeling left, in particular of gothic style towers and domes, along with more details on the top of the bridge. There’s also cannons that I have to model for the top of the ship. I am fast approaching the point where only texturing will really push the detail to the final level that I want. It’s starting to come together slowly. I’m afraid though that I may end up starting other projects at the same time, since there are other things that I do need to do soon, so this project may end up suffering. Let’s see what happens, however.

As always, like, subscribe, and share!

Progress Update: Adding in the Engines

Hello everyone,

My progress thus far has focused on the stern still. Now that I’ve added in the engines and some more stuff to the bridge, I’m getting a much better idea of what the rest of the warship will look like. Here’s some pictures:

Screen Shot 2017-05-20 at 5.11.45 PMScreen Shot 2017-05-20 at 5.11.59 PMScreen Shot 2017-05-20 at 5.12.12 PMScreen Shot 2017-05-20 at 5.12.24 PM

Of course, there’s still quite a bit more detail to add, but the work is progressing, slowly and sincerely. I’m honestly a bit surprised I’ve made it this far with this project. The model has come quite a ways since I first began and was unsure of how it’ll be modeled. The next biggest challenge, once all the modeling is complete, is going to be UV unwrapping (just writing this here makes me want to groan) and texturing as well. What sort of material this model should use, I have no idea at the moment. It’s really tough to tell from images what would work best. That’s still a bit of a ways off, but it’s worth thinking about in any event.

As always, like, subscribe, and share.

Progress Update: Gothic Windows

So today my modeling focused a lot on smaller details and once more on adding geometry to the stern. I’ve also started modeling the Gothic cathedral windows. Here’s what it looks like so far:

Screen Shot 2017-05-17 at 10.03.32 PMScreen Shot 2017-05-17 at 10.03.56 PMScreen Shot 2017-05-17 at 10.04.05 PMScreen Shot 2017-05-17 at 10.04.13 PM

I’ve added more details and started to focus on putting in the geometry for the cathedral style windows that dominate the command deck and bridge of the warship. I’ve also added other types of details as well.

As I mentioned in my last post, the main issue is that it’s really tough to tell what goes on the stern of the warship for a variety of reasons. The first is that there are many different interpretations of the warship. The second is that none of the pictures really focus too much on the detail on the stern of the warship. I’ve decided that I’m going to try my best to fill in the gaps with my own inventions (since this model isn’t exactly an Emperor class). Hopefully I’ll be able to add more of this stuff tomorrow/soon.

As always, like, subscribe, and share!